OpenAI Withdraws 3 Math Papers
- Source
- github.com
- Author
- theemathas
- Date
The withdrawn manuscripts include work on Weil classes and the rational Hodge conjecture for products of K3 surfaces. A single sign error in a shared construction invalidated all three, which shows how an error in AI-assisted mathematics can propagate across dependent results. The same update modifies 19 results and adds six Lean formalizations, bringing roughly 42% of top-line results to formal verification, while one account of the log counts proof repairs across 14 other papers. The record is useful because it is dated and specific: it shows which claims failed, why, and what was done about them. For anyone relying on AI-produced proofs, the practical lesson is that informal review missed this error, and machine-checked formalization is the check that scales. Treat unformalized results in this area as provisional until they are verified independently.
Context
One shared proof error led OpenAI to withdraw three mathematics manuscripts. Its October 7 correction log says a sign error in the paper on algebraicity of Weil classes on split abelian eightfolds invalidated an argument in that paper and a construction that two dependent papers also use. The failure therefore extended beyond the manuscript where it originated, which is why the dependent papers on Kuga-Satake correspondences and on the rational Hodge conjecture for products of K3 surfaces were withdrawn with it. The log says each withdrawn paper now carries a notice explaining the gap and linking to the archived manuscript.
Checking sign-in…
Loading comments…

