Victory! You Can Now Exclude Apps From Siri AI
- Source
- eff.org
- Author
- Thorin Klosowski (EFF)
- Date

Context
Since iOS 27.2, iPhone owners can name apps that Siri AI is not allowed to read, in an Excluded Apps list in the Siri section of Settings, and the EFF, the digital-rights group, counts it as a win for one of the requests in its Encrypt It Already campaign (EFF). At Siri AI's launch, keeping it away from a single app meant changing several confusing toggles or turning Siri AI off and going back to Siri Classic. According to the EFF, an excluded app's contents are then off limits to Siri AI, including to onscreen awareness, the feature that answers questions about whatever you are looking at. Exclude Signal and Siri cannot tell you anything about a Signal chat on screen; exclude Apple's Messages and it can no longer read or reply to texts for you. The EFF treats those lost features as proof the setting works.
The EFF's concern is encrypted messaging. Many AI features send data to the cloud for processing, so the contents of an end-to-end encrypted chat can leave the phone without the user knowing, even with protections like Apple's Private Cloud Compute, which the EFF argues fall short of encryption in its earlier analysis. Keeping Siri AI out of an app's contents means that content is not handed to it for processing anywhere. The EFF does not say whether exclusion covers every route, such as notifications, and no Apple documentation of the setting was found to check that; Signal describes it more narrowly, as protecting message content from proactive access by Siri AI.
The setting is a user's choice, made app by app. Signal, in its announcement, recommends it to macOS 27 users because it cannot block screenshots on the Mac, while asking for an opt-out that developers can set for their own app. On Android, the EFF finds the controls less clear. Gemini's Connected Apps list lets you revoke access, and Signal does not support that feature, so Gemini cannot read Signal directly. But Gemini can still read notifications if the Device Assistance connected app is on, which also powers basics like timers, and it can use screen unless you switch that off, with no per-app option. The EFF wants Google to add per-app switches and Apple to offer an on-device-only mode like Samsung's Galaxy AI.
- In iOS 27.2, adding an app under Settings > Siri > Excluded Apps stops Siri AI from accessing its contents. At launch, EFF says, blocking one app required toggling several separate options.
- Exclusion has visible costs that EFF treats as proof it works: excluding Messages stops Siri AI reading or replying to messages, and onscreen awareness no longer works inside an excluded app such as Signal.
- On Android, Gemini's app access can be revoked under Settings > Personal Intelligence > Connected Apps, but screen context cannot be set per app. Signal is absent from that list because it does not support Gemini's app access feature.
- EFF says Gemini can still read notifications, which may include Signal's, when the Device Assistance connected app is on (it also powers basics like timers), and can use screen context unless "Use screen and app data" is off.
- EFF wants Apple to go further and offer an option to use only on-device AI features, similar to what Samsung offered with Galaxy AI.
- Context and context window — Context is the information available for a generation; the context window is the capacity available to hold it.
Checking sign-in…
Loading comments…


